CONTENTS

• Introduction to the material: On Holmesians and Doyleites
• AFFABLE HAWK (Desmond MacCarthy) & CYRIL ASQUITH O...
• SHERLOCKHOLMITOS by David Leslie Murray (1932)
• MY DEAR WATSON... The Times (1932) Fourth Leader
• THE WATSON PROBLEM by S. C. Roberts (1932)
• THE PRIVATE LIFE OF SHERLOCK HOLMES review in Book...
• SHERLOCKISMUS by David Leslie Murray
• MOTHER WATSON by Cyril Connolly (1934)
• BAKER STREET STUDIES reviewed by David Leslie Murr...
• THE DIVERSION OF SCHOLARSHIP by Desmond MacCarthy
• SHERLOCKHOLMITOS*
• BOSH (Desmond MacCarthy)
• EARLY SHERLOCKIANA - Some Quotes
• THE HOLMES-MORIARTY DUEL by Eustace Portugal (1934...

On Holmesians and Doyleites

• Guilielmo, B. (ms.) "Early Sherlockiana (1927-1934)"
  

A general overview of the critical texts which gave birth to the Sherlockian movement at the end of the 1920s and early 1930s; a partial exploration of Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes stories’ history of reception. That historical sequence can be considered as its Golden Age (1927-34).

 

NB: For the definitive, and up-to-date version, see "Early Sherlockians and Sherlockiana, 1927-1934" in Clausson. N. (ed.), Re-examining Arthur Conan Doyle, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tye, 2021, pp. 141-161.

• Donley, Kate M. (2017) "Early Sherlockian scholarship: Non/fiction at play" In "Sherlock Holmes Fandom, Sherlockiana, and the Great Game," edited by Betsy Rosenblatt and Roberta Pearson, special issue, Transformative Works and Cultures, no. 23.

 An in-depth study of two periods of Sherlockian Scholarship.

• Guilielmo, B. (2013) "Desmond MacCarthy and the Chronological Problem," Saturday Review of Literature, January 2013.
  

An introduction to Desmond MacCarthy's columns in the New Statesman (1927) about many issues that will be discussed for decades by Sherlockian scholars.

• Donley, K. M. (2017) "Watson on the Wireless: Desmond MacCarthy and the BBC Radio's 'Miniature Biographies," Saturday Review of Literature, 5, 2017.   

On the liaisons dangereuses between MacCarthy's watsonian scholarship and modern biography.

• Guilielmo, B. (2011) "The Sources of Ronald Knox’s Satire," The Sherlock Holmes Journal, Vol. 30 n°2, Winter 2011

Against some persistent false beliefs concerning one of the most eminent Sherlockian of them all.